Thursday, January 26, 2012

Why I support Indiana House Bill 1367

I am moving off of school for this entry because there is a pressing issue I must write about. Indiana House Bill 1367, here is the link http://www.in.gov/legislative/bills/2012/IN/IN1367, has sent the Deaf Community in an uproar. Some of you will know what I mean when I write Deaf Community but some of you won't. The Deaf Community in Indiana believes every child with a hearing loss should use ASL as their first mode of communication with English (Bi/Bi) being taught second as a means for reading and writing. They very much oppose a child with a hearing loss learn to listen and speak. Here is a link to the Indiana School for the Deaf's website (http://www.deafhoosiers.com/) you can click on it and find their Mission Statement on being Bilingual. Also Outreach Services is located on the campus of the Deaf School. Outreach Services is suppose to be a non-bias place that parents of children with a hearing loss can go and receive information about their communication options. I ask, "How can you be non-bias when you are housed at a school that is clearly bias towards Bi/Bi communication?" I will tell you that this question has been asked by many ever since our family entered into the world of hearing loss and it can never be answered.

The reason I am blogging about this is because HB 1367 is proposing to move that facility and open one not on the Deaf Schools property and employ people who can be unbias. What exactly does that mean? I will tell you this, it means different things to different people. Hear Indiana ( http://www.hearindiana.org/) started a Facebook event for this bill and they also have a Facebook page. If you could only see how different people interpret this bill. I have read it over and over and over again and I still not see what some are seeing. The argument against the bill is basically saying that "us" (supporters of the bill) are trying to take ASL away and make all children with a hearing loss be oral. This is not even close to how I interpret this bill. I do see how they would think this because most of the people supporting the bill have children who are auditory learners (oral) but what they are not seeing is that we have either been affected by Outreach being bias towards ASL or worked with families that have had that type of experience. This is where our personal story comes into play and why I SUPPORT HB 1367.

On August 29th of 2006 Evan and I arrived at the Outreach Center at ISD for his assessments. He was getting ready to enter the public school and transition out of IN First Steps. We were sent there by our local school co-op because the services are free to all schools. (I hope we all know by now that nothing in life is really free. We taxpayers pay for this because the government gives ISD money because its a State School which in turns gives money to Outreach.) I was very hesitant on going there because Evan was an already an established auditory learner. We chose the aural/oral approach with him very early and he was and still is very successful. I informed our local co-op that wasn't really where I wanted to go but I was young and naive and decided I would give them a shot but I wanted all of Evan's paperwork to perfectly state he does not use sign language. We had used word signs with him on occasion and he did know some but that was not his first mode of communication. Walking into that building will forever be etched into my memory. Only sign language was being used! I'm going to state this ONE TIME... I AM NOT AGAINST SIGN LANGUAGE!!! I think ASL is beautiful but if you are truly working for ALL families you can NOT use one mode of communication. Back to my story. Evan started instantly playing with a Lego table and we were greeted by Jodee Crace. I had known Jodee from previous engagements and as a person I really like her. Her and I had a conversation for a few seconds, really it was me finger spelling and her being a gracious person since I'm not a signer. We were lead into a assessment room by Julie Buck and Louise Fitzpatrick where for the next 2 to 3 hours an assessment was given to my son in American Sign Language. I barely said anything because I didn't know what I was suppose to do. I remember specifically asking Julie why this was being done in ASL when Evan doesn't know it and she responded "We have to evaluate the whole child". That was the only spoken words said the whole time. One time Evan even got so upset he pushed Louise. She was shaking a rattle directly into his hearing aid and because he wouldn't sign stop, even tho he was speaking it perfectly clear, she would not stop. I cringed and hurt for my child. After the assessment was finished I was lead into another room where I was told the recommendations were Evan be immersed into the Deaf community and that he didn't need a personal FM system in public school but only a Soundfield system. These were recommendations that were going to our school system exactly the opposite of what was being requested from me.

The reason I support IN HB 1367 is because we are that family that was discriminated against. I actually filed a complaint with the IN Dept of Education because they violated my son's right according to Article 7. They did not do his assessments in his native language which is not ASL. So many people are trying to make this bill about ASL against Oral when it is about finally getting an organization in this state that is actually a safe and warm environment for all families who have children with a hearing loss. So many families are left to fend for themselves or given incorrect information to sway them in one direction.

It is TIME FOR A CHANGE in Indiana and I believe this bill could do that!!!

10 comments:

Chosen said...

Excellent way of putting it! I totally agree!
I have 2 daughters with hearing losses and both have implants. Both are in mainstream school setting. Both have interpreters. Both use Total Communication. It was my choice years ago to teach them to USE THEIR VOICE AND LISTEN. They have done this for years and it works beautifully for them. My oldest us 16 and has a lit if friends within the school system because she can communicate with them. By taking away that right from our kids, we are alienating them from society. That is not fair and that us not FREEDOM IF SPEECH!

dlefler said...

Oh my gosh - how horrible that the woman was shaking a rattle into his HA and didn't stop because he wouldn't sign it! That is outright abuse! We've actually tried to get Nolan to sign as a backup form of communication, and he absolutely refuses to do it. He WANTS to be auditory/oral. I think ALL options should be open to families of children with hearing loss.

Anonymous said...

Oh my .. My mouth is down to the floor... I cannot imagine your experience at ALL!!! Everyone - every parent has the right to choose which avenue is best for their child and no community has the right to dictate as such. As a C.O.D.A. , and a mom of an implanted 14 year old son, I am appalled at that way you and your child were treated. It certainly is reverse discrimination and very disturbing. You have my support.

Candy said...

Speechless.

Evaluate the whole child?

Gotta be kidding me.

Not how outreach should approach a child who's first language is speaking English.

(e said...

I'm sorry you and your child went through that. :( Would you mind me sharing part of your post on my blog? (with a link back, of course).

lbre969903 said...

If my blog will help parents understand that they have a choice in what is said and done with their child, then yes, share it. I do not wantto have to make it private so please be respectful! Thanks!

wascher5 said...

That is only present. What about long term? I will wait until he become an adult and I know what he will say. "mom why don't u let me learn asl?"
my experience is the opposite. Outreach gave me everything and I took an advanagte to use it all. I didn't pick one. I had it all for my 3 children.

lbre969903 said...

wascher5: Are you saying my son will say that or your son? I fully support whatever decision you chose for your child..

WW said...

I find this very hard to believe. I know these people personally. I, myself, am a graduate of the Indiana School for the Deaf. I have a feeling you misunderstood the situation.

lbre969903 said...

WW: Thank you for your respectful comment. I can understand that you would question this, but I know it happened because I was there and I have the report and the complaints that were filed with the IN Dept of Education. I would like to ask; how do you misunderstand someone doing an assessment in ASL? how do you misunderstand a Deaf adult shaking a rattle into a child's hearing aid and refusing to stop because he is signing the word "stop"?