Wednesday, July 8, 2009

How far have we come?

I finished Heather Whitestone's book a couple days ago and have struggled with whether or not to post what my feelings are about some of the situations she had to go through. See I really don't like to get into the "methodology battle" when it comes to deaf/hh kiddos and I think some of the things I am about to print might ruffle some feathers. I have prayed about this for 2 days now and it is just weighing on me so maybe God is telling me to write it out so I can move on.

First off this was an awesome book and I think everyone should read it. Plus when I was finished I went on line and found her personal website and found out so much more about her and her family. I took the book back to the library so I can not quote anything from the book so probably will be paraphrasing things.

One of the first things that caught my eye was how much research her mother did on her behalf for communication. This woman took her time, visited schools, read articles and did research on all of the options of communication for her daughter and in the end chose what she felt was best for Heather and her family. I commend her for that!! I remember those days when we were doing this for Evan and wondering and praying if we were making the right decision for him and our family. I remember thinking what was everyone's opinion going to be and how would I be able to handle their opinions?

Next was the continued "therapy" Daphne and her family was able to provide for Heather all the time. I am telling you that is one dedicated mother. She knew if she was going to choose this for her daughter that everyone would need to be involved and be a willing participant in her daughter's growth. So why is it that this method is called taking the easy way? I didn't read anywhere in this book how this journey was easy for this mother. I just read a mother whose dedication to her daughter is everlasting.

My last insight for this was when Heather entered the Miss Deaf Alabama contest and was ridiculed and ultimately not picked because she chose to speak and didn't know how to sign. This just made my heart hurt and brought me back to the time I had a lady tell me straight to my face what a disservice I was doing to my child for not teaching him how to sign and how I was robbing him of his natural language and that my child belongs to her and her people and one day I would wake up and realize that I had made a horrible mistake and she hoped that my child would see the light when he got older and come back to his people. At the time of this statement my child was only 12 months old..

In closing... Again this book was awesome and I encourage you to read it if you haven't already but I question "How far have we really come to bridge the gap between the hearing/Deaf world?" Maybe it is different in other states.. I can only hope and pray that it is!!!

1 comment:

lbre969903 said...

Ok, I don't want to fight about it, but it was a Miss Deaf (big D Deaf) pageant. I would think she would know that knowing ASL would be a requirement. from "Miss Kat's Parents"

Sorry Miss Kat's mommy I deleted your comment.. I just want to respond. I am not real sure how I feel about the whole capital D lower d and such. I understand what you are saying but really why would a pageant allow her to enter knowing full well she didn't sign.. That is where it got me.. If the rules specifically state "you can only sign" "no talking" then I wold understand and would question why she entered but to my knowledge it was not that way. And she is deaf in my opinion so she should have been able to enter and be respected and appreciated just like the other girls.